Beyond Success Stories: What Survivor Bias Can Teach Leaders

When we think about success, it’s easy to picture the shining peak of an iceberg glimmering in the spotlight. We see successful entrepreneurs, famous stars, brilliant scientists, and are tempted to think their paths to greatness were straightforward. The stories we hear make it seem as if their success was inevitable. But is this really the full picture?

Behind every well-known name and each celebrated achievement, lies a hidden world of stories—the unspoken stories of those who didn’t make it. For every success story that captures our imagination, countless other attempts have ended in failure, without the same recognition.

This skewed focus on those who have “made it” while ignoring those who didn’t is what we call Survivor Bias. It’s a cognitive distortion that leads us to think success is more attainable or typical than it truly is, simply because we’re only seeing part of the picture.

Survivor Bias is a sneaky phenomenon that distorts our understanding of success. It pushes us to focus solely on the visible “survivors,” or those who have achieved their goals, while ignoring the data on those who didn’t. This can lead to a misleading view of what it takes to succeed.

It’s a bit like looking at the world through a telescope: we’re only seeing a limited part of the picture, which leads us to assumptions based on incomplete information.

Imagine you’re looking at a study of startups and see that 90% of them fail within the first year. The remaining 10% stand out, and it’s tempting to think, “If they did it, I can too!” Survivor Bias here nudges us to focus on that successful minority, ignoring that these are the exceptions, not the rule.

It’s as if our brains become fixated on the “lucky ones” who succeeded and quietly overlook the larger portion who didn’t make it.

Consider an example from World War II. Fighter planes would often return from missions with damage from enemy fire, and military analysts logically thought it made sense to reinforce those areas with the most bullet holes.

But a mathematician named Abraham Wald looked at the situation differently and asked a simple yet profound question: “What about the planes that didn’t make it back?”

Wald’s insight was that the planes that returned with bullet holes in non-critical areas were able to survive the damage and make it back to base. Meanwhile, planes hit in more vital spots, such as the cockpit or fuel tank, were likely shot down. If they only reinforced the parts that had holes, they’d overlook the most vulnerable areas, leading to potentially disastrous results.

Wald’s analysis taught them to focus on the “invisible population” of planes that didn’t survive—a classic example of Survivor Bias leading even experts down the wrong path by focusing on only the visible cases.

The stories of those who have succeeded are enticing, like pieces of a mosaic that shine brightly and attract attention. But Survivor Bias has us focused on these successful pieces alone, giving us an incomplete view. It’s like admiring a few beautiful tiles and thinking we understand the whole artwork - when, in reality, many other less sparkly tiles add depth and complexity to the image.

Think about the advice successful entrepreneurs often give: “Take risks! Go all in, and the reward will be worth it!” They mean well, but their voices are part of the “chorus of winners,” the people who survived the risks and found success.

But what about those who took the same risks and didn’t succeed? Their voices are quiet, barely heard amid the noise of victory. Survivor Bias often omits those who don’t fit the “success story” mold, creating a distorted view where success seems more accessible than it really is.

The stories we celebrate often ignore the role that luck plays in success. Focusing only on the winners, it’s easy to draw a straight line from actions to results, overlooking the many factors beyond their control.

The truth is, luck often plays a substantial role, but Survivor Bias can make us believe that anyone who simply follows a certain set of steps will succeed.

For example, hearing about a friend who won big in the lottery might make you think, “That could be me!” Survivor Bias doesn’t remind you of the millions who bought tickets and lost.

Our brains, eager for shortcuts, focus on the positive outcome without considering the invisible losses, creating an illusion that makes the improbable seem within reach.

Our brains are efficient but sometimes misleading; they love to simplify things, even at the cost of accuracy. Survivor Bias is often linked with another shortcut, known as availability bias.

This bias makes us prioritize information that is easiest to recall—typically the most recent, vivid, or dramatic examples. When success stories are everywhere, they become “mentally available,” tricking us into believing they are more common than they are.

Imagine you’re considering a big decision, like starting your own business. Your brain, trying to be helpful, recalls stories of people who turned their passions into hugely successful ventures.

It remembers the inspiration, the rags-to-riches stories, and nudges you toward thinking, “If they can do it, so can I.” It’s an illusion created by focusing on the visible winners and overlooking the hidden tales of those who faced setbacks.

Knowing how easily our minds can be influenced by Survivor Bias can help us make better choices. Here’s how to avoid falling into this trap:

Question the Information and Its Sources
If you find yourself impressed by a new miracle product with glowing testimonials, pause and ask yourself: “Where are the stories of those it didn’t work for?” It’s easy to get swept away by visible success stories, but always seek out additional information to see the whole picture. Remember, it’s only one branch on the tree—there’s often more you’re not seeing. Read about Logic must rule the world - may be, may be, may be

Critically Analyze Data, Even If It Seems Obvious
Remember the WWII plane story: the obvious solution was to reinforce damaged areas on returning planes. Wald’s insight to consider the planes that didn’t come back teaches us to question what we aren’t seeing and to think critically, even if a conclusion seems clear.

Consider All Contributing Factors and Circumstances
Every story of success has layers. Suppose you hear that someone became wealthy from a single investment. Before jumping to conclusions, ask about the details: Was it one investment, or part of a broader strategy? Context matters, and it’s crucial to look at the complete situation to avoid seeing a skewed version of reality.

Survivor Bias is a subtle yet powerful trap, one that can lead us to form unrealistic expectations about success. By focusing only on those who “made it,” we miss out on understanding the full picture—the countless efforts that went uncelebrated but still shaped the overall landscape of success.

Recognizing this bias gives us a way to face our own challenges with clarity. When we broaden our view to consider not only the success stories but also the quieter tales of resilience, we gain a more balanced understanding of what it truly takes to reach our goals.

In the end, success is rarely a formula—it’s a complex journey full of factors both seen and unseen. By appreciating both the bright and the hidden tiles of the mosaic, we equip ourselves to approach life’s challenges with both hope and realism.

I also recommend you to read related articles:
Assertiveness is the skill of self-confidence
Thinking is what makes us who we are
People's emotions spread, influencing others
Unique business psychology with TED Talks
Why we get angry and how to learn to control ourselves
How to use psychology in the business?

UnitiQ offers on-demand HR services, specializing in flexible, cost-effective solutions for talent acquisition, HR operations, and strategic people management. By providing immediate access to HR experts, UnitiQ allows companies to handle specific tasks or manage entire HR functions as needed.

Their sector-specific professionals help businesses build teams aligned with company values, bringing fresh perspectives that support growth, culture, and engagement. With a network of industry experts and a dedicated point of contact, UnitiQ ensures smooth collaboration tailored to each client's unique needs.

We are happy to help you with Talent Acquisition and HR tasks, please contact me, Olga Fedoseeva, Founder at UnitiQ, directly:

My Telegram
My LinkedIn